Message Max Lenght

Kommentare

143 Kommentare

  • timothysboxers 🐍

    Trusty McCoolGirl,

    While it irks me, I hadn't bothered testing it.

    For the sake of science, I did just carry out a few scenarios and what I can advise is that Discord seems to count the end of line/paragraph mark as a character (where word/gdocs do not—though they do show character count with and without spaces). A space is a character, so I had expected that to be included in the count. Technically speaking, so is the end of paragraph mark, and if you really want to get into it, it could count for two characters: Carriage return and Line feed.

    So in a situation where you are posting multi-paragraph messages or attempting to do a nicely formatted post, this will eat into the character count that you have available to use. So, if you—like most of us do—use word or gdocs to prepare posts, then the difference in the manner in which characters are counted may lead to you having a bad time.

    I feel less annoyed about it now and modify my earlier complaint about it being inaccurate—downgrading it to merely being inconsistent with typical methods for character counting via word or gdocs.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • TrustyasHeck

    Timothysboxers,

    Ugh. No wonder... I think I suspected something of the like, but that doesn't make it any less irritating that we have even fewer characters than we thought. The fact that we really, functionally, only have a fraction of that bothers me so much even if it's more reasonable than what we were thinking re: inconsistent numbers. If someone says that there are 2000 characters available, they should mean 2000 non-space or non-invisible characters such as letters, punctuation marks, symbols, numbers, etc.

    The introductory (or original) post for this thread is exactly 2055 with spaces, 2018 if the note is removed (I believe there was a slight miscalculation there) but regardless the fact that you can't even fit that much into a single post really hurts. There are just so many hurdles to run through because of that. I really hope that the Discord Staff Team sees this thread and decides to up the limit for certain people, or just to increase it a teensy bit for everyone. Even a little would be so nice because it all adds up and could help cut down on how many posts we have to make for a single message. (I'd still love the 20,000 limit but I'm not about to assume that we'll get that much; I don't know the inner workings of Discord well enough to state whether it'd be feasible.)

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Dtanotrew

    I feel like 200 would be excessive to some extent but even if it were bumped to 50 to 100 or so words would be really nice. And an increased limit on posts would certainly be appreciated, especially if you're typing up an "essay" only for it to be denied as it was too long.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Sola

    It would definitely be great to set custom character count limits on a per-channel basis. Just flat increasing it globally would be a catastrophe.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • ! Galletita Oreo
    I think it would be a lack of control, anyway you can split the message into 2
    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • meowfsy

    My main discord server has a great community and we use it for a living world Dungeons and Dragons campaign. We have many channels dedicated to roleplay which are used everyday. One thing that is really frustrating for a roleplayer, is the character limit.

    It would be really great if there were a character limit toggle in the server settings. I can see why the limit is useful, but as a server owner it makes me feel very frustrated that I can't remove or increase this limit. Especially since the limit is incredibly small.

    I'm really shocked this hasn't yet been looked at/implemented.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Altarin

    Thats why i said set it only to channel settings. If you have annoucements/guides channel i highly doubt you want this channel to be publicaly writable. Which means only people with permissions can write there, just as they would anyway, but instead of 2 or 5 or more posts they could only write that one.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • TechMaster85

    Add a permission that you can add to a role with certain character limits you choose.

     

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • mch7

    I'd love to but I'm not a Discord wizard, where is that permission?  Or how can I go about it?  Advice / Help appreciated.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Ein

    Bump!

    I'm surprised this still isn't a thing.
    The 2k character limit is extremely frustrating, more so when you're trying to make the post look anything decent while retaining the info you're sharing.
    While 200 for nicknames seems excessive for me, I won't complain, it would help others if not myself.
    The abuse is there, but like many have already suggested, then maybe it could be implemented as a permission, either way there are workarounds for it and it REALLY needs to be implemented.

    I run into the limit 24/7, hurts the most when you're typing on mobile since it deletes your message while giving you the limit message.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Sandra Gomen

    That is not really necessary. You can spit up the text for your server rules or whatever you want.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • TrustyasHeck

    Yeah, thinking about it, it would be great if you could simply (instead of having a global increase) set it to be a certain character limit for certain server roles, for certain server channels, and in certain dms/group dms. Especially since that would allow server owners to edit it to make the post limit something that's reasonable to them, without having everyone have that issue of way too many people posting way too much at once.

    There's some really nice feedback on this so far, and I'm also surprised that this hasn't gotten more attention from the devs. It could probably be seen as a decent amount of work, but it would make a huge impact for a lot of users to be able to alter the character limit. The nickname limit-- that's far less important, and it's more of a fantasy since it'd be way more open to abuse. But I'm shocked there doesn't seem to be any discussion about the potential opening for selective increases in character limit, especially with the mobile issues.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Connerrrrrr™🎃🎃🎃🎃
    Duplicated
    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Malachi

    I would also really love this feature, even if you just add it as a setting for certain channels. I'm a future guild leader for the upcoming WoW Classic launch, and I started forming a guild months in advance. Every so often I would make an announcement, saying where we're at, what we'll do in certain situations of news, and just general coordination. Every single time I talked in our announcement channel I'd have to split my messages in to multiple. Why? It's such a pain. And you know they don't have any reason other than what they believe is "courtesy," because that's what the error message is! Firstly, courteous to whom? The people that are going to get all the text I want to send regardless, except as 3 messages instead of 1? And why is it by default more courteous to send multiple messages? Whom said you get to define courteous? Discord is a bunch of kids that are withholding power when they do not know they are or even need to be.

    Make the change.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • 0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • irkedhoe

    @Suspense thank you. I genuinely thought I was alone in this because it is so irritating

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Trojaner

    great all we needed now is just even more spam

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • DerEric

    At least they should remove this cap for owners.
    It is really annoying for a rule text/announcements.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Russa

    PLEASE fix this!!!! I run a paragraph roleplay Discord and this limit is a NIGHTMARE. Our group averages about 5000 characters per post, which we have to keep breaking down. Setting up a story can take upwards of 10000 characters and I'm SO sick of struggling with the limit. We keep our gmail open the whole time we have discord up and have to break it up and copy and paste and copy and paste.

    Then you copy and paste one section, and it won't go through because you are one or two characters off, so you have to return to your gmail and copy and paste again hoping you got it right this time.

    Honestly, this is driving me insane. We used to have a designated forum for roleplaying, but those kind of forums are becoming less and less common over time and they don't have any of the features we need. They are not app friendly, they don't send notifications and making more topics is very difficult. 

    Please please please please please just have it so the administrator can decide the character limit!!!! Our group is this close to just leaving completely.

    Those of you who do not understand. This 'feature' is crippling for authors and roleplayers and we aren't the only ones struggling with it. It's pretty simple to let individual servers decide what limit works best for them. I'm not saying there should be two options "Turn on or turn off". I want to be able to say whether posts should be 2000, or 5000 or more.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • KekoKitten

    Oh my goodness, this is like the most annoying thing in the world!!! I'm not a role player, or an author, or anything like that. I'm just trying to manage a server. And EVERY TIME I try to post a message containing info, EVERY SINGLE TIME, I have to break it up into 2 or 3 pieces. 

    Now, this isn't too intense for me, it's not like I have 10,000 character messages or something, no. I just have around 3000-6000 character messages. And it's been a real big annoyance. Especially since I usually space up my messages into paragraphs, like I'm doing now. There isn't an indent feature in discord, so when I have to split my message, it will look like one paragraph is with another! 

    All I'm asking is to have the character limit reach AT LEAST 4,000 characters per message. If they do even more, I'll be surprised. At this point, I am fine with it being a Nitro feature. I just want to type in longer messages. Maybe it could be just an admin feature, or a role toggle, like most people say. We just want to type more!!! This is literally the only flaw I have with Discord, and if this doesn't get fixed, it will drive me INSANE!

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Kawphi

    I'm sure I'm just echoing everyone's concerns but I believe how these types of request work is that the more people request it and leave comments, the more likely Discord team will review the request and make a decision. 

    This, as others have mentioned, is extremely irritating. I lead a clan for a popular game and we use our Discord to post Clan Rules, upcoming updates for the game, weekly clan news updates, events, etc. so I'm constantly hitting the 2000 character limit and usually without realizing it, which on its own is incredibly infuriating. I realize that people spamming 2000+ character posts could be annoying but if it's locked behind roles or admin rights, I don't really see any issue to it. I also find it hard to believe that spamming is the reason you don't enable this since you're just making us break up our posts into 2-3 separated posts. Aren't users just going to get multiple notifications for that instead? 

    For the sake of all your Discord users, please just do something to change this.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • EKOmylife

    I also agree. It should be customizable for mods and admins to choose the character limit. So if there are role-play or story servers, they can set it to a higher character limit. Or if there is a server frequent with spammers, they can set it to a lower character limit.

    Yes, you can just splice each text to different sections, but understandably this can be tedious and slightly frustrating to do so.

    I also have an idea in mind. So the server I moderate has a rules channel where only other mods and I can post...well...rules for the server. But because of the limit, I can’t write as much without having to split the message. We also have a general channel where all our members can converse. That’s where spammers may be frequent. So maybe you can set the character limit separately for each channel. So for the rules channel, it can have a 20k character limit, and for the general it has about a 2k limit.

    You can also change the character limit for specific roles too. I think with this, you can avoid spammers while having this feature on discord.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • resynth1943

    You should use something like Google Docs to share large text documents over Discord, as Discord really isn't cut out for this in my opinion, which is reinforced by your complaints above.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Fillix

    Here is an example of the channels I have created for the rp server. Discord is the perfect platform to divide people into one on one stories or switching locations etc. It's just the character limit that is bugging us.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Fillix

    I'm not asking for it to be removed indefinitely.
    I'm asking to give the server owner the option to turn the limit on or off. So people that start coding or story servers, they can turn it off and post their large texts without problems.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Epsilon13

    I know so many ppl who would love to raise the character limit. We use it for RP and character building and basically everyone in the chat hits the limit and feels bad about having to cut their content down 

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • TechmandanCZ

    There should be an option - I want somewhere lower limit, like 1k chars, but somewhere the 2k limit is too low for some things. There should be an option for roles, where you could edit the limit (for example up to 10-15k)

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • whiteghost

    I agree. in a perfect world I would say it should be like 10,000 to 12,000, however since i know that's probably ridiculous I think a good number would be 5,000 or 4,000.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Naijeru

    100% agree with the suggestion. Roles that have the administrator permission should be exempt from a character limit in their own servers. Best-case scenario is a completely customizable character limit by role and channel, with the ability to remove it in a channel all together. Direct messages, as other people have said, shouldn't have a limit at all.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink
  • Aiden

    So many Discord RP'ers want this. As many have said, just have it as an admin option for certain channels. Perhaps it could just be doubled to 4000 characters in general? That would actually help quite a bit.

    0
    Aktionen für Kommentare Permalink

Bitte melden Sie sich an, um einen Kommentar zu hinterlassen.